Muckaty Radioactive Waste Dump
Expansion of Welfare Quarantining


– Background

Beyond Nuclear Initiative’s weblog:
“This site is a snapshot of current nuclear free campaigns
in Australia, particularly focusing on the proposal for a
federal radioactive waste dump in the Northern Territory.”

WGAR News: Nuclear waste dump in the Northern Territory (2 Mar 10)

WGAR News: Muckaty Station Nuclear Waste Dump (20 Mar 10)

WGAR News: Nuclear Waste Dump … (28 Mar 10)

– National Day of Action

ASEN – Australian Student Environment Network:
National Day of Action
against Muckaty Radioactive Waste Dump: 12th April!
1 Apr 10: “On 12 April, the Senate will hold a public
hearing in Darwin as part of its inquiry into the
legislation that will lock-in Muckaty as the site for a
national radioactive waste dump. There will be no hearing
in Tennant Creek, effectively SILENCING many Traditional
Owners, who will be unable to travel to Darwin.
SHOW YOUR SUPPORT to the Muckaty Traditional Owners who have
been opposing the plan to dump dangerous nuclear waste on
their country since it was first proposed.”

– Media Releases

Greens MPs:
Govt admits six jobs will be created at Muckaty waste dump
30 Mar 10: “The Senate Inquiry into the Commonwealth
Government’s radioactive waste dump legislation has heard a
total of six jobs will be created at a future Muckaty
Station nuclear dump, near Tennant Creek. “This puts to
rest the myth that somehow this waste dump will create
benefits for Aboriginal people or the wider Tennant Creek
community,” said Senator Scott Ludlam, Greens spokesperson
on nuclear issues.”

Greens MPs:
Greens to question secret Muckaty contract in waste dump inquiry
29 Mar 10: “The Australian Greens will question the two
parties involved in signing a secret contract that led to
the nomination of Muckaty Station, near Tennant Creek, as
the only proposed site for Australia’s first ever
radioactive waste dump. “This inquiry will give the
Commonwealth Government and the Northern Land Council the
chance to finally be open with Northern Territorians and all
Australians about the exact nature of the deal struck under
a process which Labor described as illegitimate,” said
Senator Scott Ludlam, Greens spokesperson on nuclear issues.”

– News

Brisbane Times: Ngapa people reject nuclear waste dump
3 Apr 10: “Traditional owners of land that could house a
nuclear waste dump have protested against the plan, saying
they were excluded from the process. … About 250 people
including traditional owners and anti-nuclear campaigners
marched in Tennant Creek on Saturday, directing their anger
at both Resources Minister Martin Ferguson and the Northern
Land Council (NLC) – who they say overlooked them.”

Tennant & District Times:
Big turnout expected for Muckaty rally
1 Apr 10: “HUNDREDS of people are expected to turn out in
Tennant Creek on Saturday to rally against the proposed
nuclear waste dump at Muckaty. Natalie Wasley from the
Beyond Nuclear Initiative said the people the Federal
Government are attempting to silence with draconian new
legislation would turn out to voice their opposition.”

ABC Alice Springs: Dump site row put to Aboriginal dance-off
1 Apr 10: “Aboriginal people from the Barkly region say
they will test claims to a potential nuclear waste dump
site by holding a traditional dancing session.”

Indymedia Australia: Proposed Muckaty nuclear waste dump
no benefit to traditional owners
31 Mar 10: “The Government has admitted that only 6 jobs
will be created by the Nuclear Waste dump on Muckaty
Station, and none of them are likely to go to traditional
people. “This puts to rest the myth that somehow this waste
dump will create benefits for Aboriginal people or the
wider Tennant Creek community,” said Senator Scott Ludlam,
Greens spokesperson on nuclear issues.”

ABC: Long term radiation from possible dump needs attention
31 Mar 10: “The deputy chair of the Senate committee
examining the proposed national nuclear waste dump near
Tennant Creek says the management of long-term radiation
needs more attention.”

ABC: Greens want Government to dump waste ‘secrecy’
30 Mar 10: “The Greens say they will use today’s Senate
inquiry into a proposed nuclear waste dump to demand the
release of documents nominating a Northern Territory
station as the preferred site. A Senate inquiry is sitting
in Canberra today to examine the proposal to situate the
dump at Muckaty Station, north of Tennant Creek.”

Brisbane Times: NT nuclear waste dump to create six jobs
30 Mar 10: “A nuclear waste dump to be built in the heart
of Australia will employ only six people, yet the
traditional owners who consented to the deal hope it will
create prosperity for generations.”

ABC: Senate hears dump will ‘build children’s future’
30 Mar 10: “A Ngapa land owner has told a Senate inquiry
there is no reason a nuclear waste dump should not be built
at Muckaty Station, north of Tennant Creek. Amy Lauder told
the inquiry a nuclear waste dump at Muckaty Station will
help her people build a better life for their children.”

NT News: NT not able to cope with nuke accident, says Government
29 Mar 10: “MOST Territory hospitals and the Port of Darwin
are not equipped to deal with a radioactive waste incident
or interest from “sophisticated criminal groups”, the NT
Government has said.”

ABC: Ferguson evades protest through back-door escape
29 Mar 10: “The Federal Resources Minister Martin Ferguson
has avoided protesters in Darwin by leaving through the
workers entrance of a popular tourist attraction.”

Flickr: Madeline Hudson speaking against the proposed
nuclear waste dump at Muckaty Station
29 Mar 10: “Madeline told the crowd:
“Our Federal Resources and Energy Minister Martin Ferguson
has decided that Muckaty is the designated spot, the site
for the national radioactive waste dump. … Now this
decision is a politically based decision. It is not based
on science, environmental or ethical considerations. It is
another example of exploiting an already disenfranchised
and minority group in our society.””

ABC: Traditional owners put hands up for nuclear dump
29 Mar 10: “Traditional land owners from the Northern
Territory have visited Australia’s only nuclear reactor to
see what they are in for if a radioactive waste dump is
built on their land.”

ANSTO: ANSTO welcomes Npaga visitors
29 Mar 10: “Representatives of the Ngapa people,
traditional owners of Muckaty Station in the Northern
Territory, were taken on an extensive tour of ANSTO’s
facilities at Lucas Heights on Monday, 29 March.”

– Video

YouTube: Madeline Hudson on stopping nuclear waste storage
at Muckaty Station
29 Mar 10: “Madeline Hudson from Friends of the Earth spoke
about the campaign against the nuclear waste storage dump
at Muckaty Station.”

ABC: Muckaty Station owners visit nuclear reactor
29 Mar 10: “Traditional owners of Muckaty Station, near
Tennant Creek in the Northern Territory, say they will
accept a nuclear waste dump being built near their land.”


– Background

Parliament of Australia: Senate Community Affairs Committee
Inquiry into Social Security and Other Legislation Amendment …
[Includes: Submissions received by the Committee;
Documents Tabled at hearings; Additional Information received]

Stop the Intervention: Racial Discrimination Act – New Legislation

WGAR News: New NT Intervention laws that extend welfare quarantining (12 Feb 10)

WGAR News: New NT Intervention laws that extend income management (19 Mar 10)

– Speech from STICS Forum

Stop the Intervention:
The Failure of the Rudd Government’s Aboriginal Policy
An Address delivered by
Professor the Honourable Alastair Nicholson AO RFD QC
29 Mar 10: “This is disgraceful legislation which
perpetuates the paternalism and racial discrimination
inherent in the Intervention. It is a disturbing extension
of bureaucratic powers and the power of the executive over
welfare recipients and seems to reflect a philosophy more
in tune with that of the previous Government that what one
would expect of a Labor Government.”

– Media Release

Rollback the Intervention: Media Release – 31 March 2010
31 Mar 10: “Federal Indigenous Affairs Minister Jenny
Macklin needs to stop perpetuating misinformation about
income management and its supposed benefits, particularly
to children, says a spokesperson for the Intervention
Rollback Action Group, which is based in Alice Springs.
There is no evidence, either in Australia or
internationally, that income management helps
underprivileged people to deal with issues arising from
their circumstances. The measure in fact goes again the
government’s own policy of social inclusion. Extending the
measure to other areas of disadvantage around the country
will not help people who are struggling to cope with issues
impacting on their lives but will add to their psychological
and financial stress.”

– Opinion and/or Analysis

The Stump – A Crikey Group Blog:
Will Caucus allow unproven, dangerous changes to income management?
31 Mar 10: “On the one side is Alastair Nicholson, nearly
all major welfare agencies, including sole parent groups,
other women’s groups, Indigenous Doctors, Academic
researchers, a report from the Australian Institute of
Health and Welfare, some statistics and one small
longitudinal research project who all oppose continuing and
extending compulsory income management in the NT and
potentially throughout Australia. … ” Eva Cox

– Radio

ABC Radio National Breakfast: Welfare quarantining
30 Mar 10: “The federal government’s proposed legislation
to expand compulsory income management across the Northern
Territory is expected to come before the Senate when
parliament resumes in May. This would see the controversial
measure of income quarantining extended to all Australians
on welfare, including white families.”
[Includes guest Alastair Nicholson, Former Chief Justice of the Family Court]

ABC Radio National Breakfast:
Minister responds to welfare quarantining criticism
31 Mar 10: “Yesterday Breakfast spoke with former chief
justice of the Family Court Alastair Nicholson, who has
been critical of the federal government’s plan to introduce
income quarantining across the Northern Territory. He
argued the proposed legislation, to be debated in the
Senate in May, is a ‘sham’ and that the Minister for
Indigenous Affairs Jenny Macklin is misrepresenting the
results of consultations held by the government.”
[Includes guest Jenny Macklin, Indigenous Affairs Minister]

ABC Radio National Life Matters: Income management
25 Mar 10: “A hot topic at the ACOSS Conference, which
kicks off today, will be income management. The federal
government and the welfare sector are at loggerheads over
it. The government has legislation currently in the Senate
which would see a national roll-out of the policy, which
partially quarantines social security payments to buy food
and other essentials.”
[Includes guests: John Falzon from St Vincent de Paul;
David Glasgow, who’s involved in an income management trial
in Cape York]

– News

Koori Mail: NSWALC backs Nicholson on welfare reform
[scroll down page] http://www.koorimail.com/index.php
31 Mar 10: “THE NSW Aboriginal Land Council has supported
former Family Court Chief Justice Alastair Nicholson’s
‘searing’ condemnation of the Rudd Government’s Indigenous
policies … NSWALC Chairperson Bev Manton said the land
council feared that the Senate would pass the Government’s
proposed welfare reforms – including extension of
compulsory income management to all welfare recipients –
before Aboriginal people knew about or understood them.”

Koori Mail: Macklin defends income management plans
[scroll down page] http://www.koorimail.com/index.php
31 Mar 10: “FEDERAL Indigenous Affairs Minister Jenny
Macklin has fended off criticisms of her proposal to extend
compulsory income management beyond NT Intervention
communities to welfare recipients nationwide. Ms Macklin
told ABC Radio that most of more than 500 of people
consulted over the measure supported it, and insisted that
welfare recipients could avoid the measure by getting their
kids to school regularly.”

Australian: Noel Pearson hails welfare quarantining extension
31 Mar 10: “NOEL Pearson has called the Rudd government’s
extension of mandatory income management across the
Northern Territory a “historic leap” into a new era.”

WAtoday: Former top judge slams NT action
30 Mar 10: “A FORMER chief justice of the Family Court,
Alastair Nicholson, QC, says Kevin Rudd is failing
indigenous Australians by continuing the Northern Territory
intervention and paying lip service to equality. …
Professor Nicholson said the Prime Minister had avoided the
”searing moral challenge” of forced assimilation, and he
asked why Mr Rudd ”continued to roll over like a puppy”
in support of the intervention.”

ABC: Universal welfare quarantining will ‘punish’
30 Mar 10: “A former chief justice of the Family Court has
criticised the Federal Government’s push to roll out
welfare quarantining to all recipients. Judge Alistair
Nicholson, who prepared the ‘Will They Be Heard’ report
examining the Government’s consultation efforts on the
Northern Territory Intervention, believes the welfare
measure will remain discriminatory even after being
applied to everyone.”

Koori Mail: Welfare legislation ‘disgraceful’, ‘a sham’
[scroll down page] http://www.koorimail.com/index.php
29 Mar 10: “A FORMER Family Court chief judge says Federal
Government proposed welfare reforms perpetuate, rather than
remove, racism under the NT Intervention. Alastair
Nicholson told a forum in Sydney tonight that planned
income management of welfare recipients nationwide still
targeted Aboriginal people and would not restore the Racial
Discrimination Act in the NT. Prof Nicholson urged the
public to pressure the Parliament to reject a related bill
currently before the Senate.”

– Of related interest

SMH: First welfare penalties for truancy
29 Mar 10: “THE federal government has for the first time
suspended the welfare payments of parents because their
children were not attending school. The suspensions took
place in the Northern Territory just before the last school
year ended, under a controversial trial that links school
enrolment and attendance to welfare payments.”

CAAMA Radio News
(Central Australian Aboriginal Media Association):
30 Mar 10: “Some families restricted from Centrelink
payments due to children not attending school.”


  1. […] WGAR Working Group for Aboriginal Rights (Australia) « 04/04/2010: MUCKATY RADIOACTIVE WASTE DUMP; WELFARE QUARANTINING […]

  2. […] WGAR News: Muckaty Radioactive Waste Dump … (4 Apr 10)https://wgar.wordpress.com/2010/04/06/04042010-muckaty-radioactive-waste-dump-welfare-quarantining/ […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: